A Proposed Federal Rule Could Put Insurance Agents on a 30-Day Clock. Is Your Paper Trail Ready?
A proposed CMS rule would change how agents are suspended and terminated. Here is how small insurance agencies can get their records in order before it is final.

On November 16, 2026, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services announced a proposed rule called Comprehensive Regulations To Uncover Suspicious Healthcare, or CRUSH. It was published in the Federal Register on November 19. If you run an independent insurance agency that sells ACA Marketplace, Medicare, or Medicaid-related plans, it is worth a careful read. It is only a proposal, and nothing changes today. But it shows where oversight is heading.
What the proposal says
According to the rule text, CMS is responding to more than 624,000 consumer complaints from 2023 to 2025 about unauthorized enrollments or plan switches, including roughly 300,000 in 2025 alone. Key proposed changes affecting agents and brokers:
- A lower bar for suspension. The trigger would move from "reasonable suspicion of fraud" to a "credible allegation of abusive conduct," which CMS says can come "from any source," including patterns found through data analysis.
- A 30-day window to refute. Agents would have 30 calendar days to refute a noncompliance finding. CMS says termination is possible even if the agent takes corrective action afterward.
- New disqualifiers. Registration could be denied or terminated for certain convictions, current exclusion from a federal program, or a license suspended or revoked in another state. (Summaries differ on whether the rule covers certain felonies only or misdemeanors too, so read the rule text.)
- Longer bans. CMS proposes bans on future Marketplace agreements of 10 years or more for the most severe violations.
Comments are due around January 19, 2027. Confirm the exact deadline on the official docket (CMS-2026-0826) before filing. No date has been announced for a final rule. An industry group has warned the rule "could crush" agents, but that is advocacy, not CMS's position.
Why records matter most
If a finding can be triggered by a data pattern and you have only 30 days to refute it, your best defense is evidence you can pull up quickly: who you spoke with, when, and what they agreed to. The rule text indicates that an agent's own call records can help show what actually happened. Small agencies often keep this scattered across personal phones, email threads, and spreadsheets.
A practical documentation checklist
- Log every client contact in one place. Calls, texts, emails, and meetings should land on the client's record in your CRM, with date and time.
- Capture consent in writing. Send a short confirmation after each enrollment or plan change that restates what the client chose. Store the reply.
- Keep an audit trail. Use tools that record who changed what and when, so you can show a clean history.
- Standardize call notes. A short template (reason for call, plan discussed, client decision, next step) beats free-form notes.
- Track licenses and certifications. Set automated reminders for renewals and state license status for every producer on your team.
- Define a response plan. Decide in advance who gathers records if a notice arrives, and how fast. Thirty days goes quickly.
- Retain records on a schedule. Check your carrier contracts and state rules for retention periods, and automate archiving.
Where automation helps
Most of this checklist is repetitive, which is why it suits automation. A CRM can send consent confirmations automatically after each enrollment, attach call and message history to the client record, and remind your team about renewals. Automated follow-up also helps with the other side of the complaint problem: clients who hear from you at the right times are less likely to be confused by a plan change they did not expect.
What to do now
- Read the proposed rule or a trusted summary from your compliance counsel or trade association.
- Consider submitting a comment before the deadline if the rule would affect your agency.
- Start tightening your recordkeeping now. These habits help under any rule.
This post is general information, not legal advice. The rule is a proposal and may change before it is final. Talk to your compliance advisor about your agency's obligations.
Want help building a consent-and-follow-up workflow in your CRM? LemAid sets up automations for small businesses so your records stay organized without extra work.
Want This Built For Your Business?
Schedule a personalized walkthrough with LemAid and see how custom website design and automated CRM workflows can capture, convert, and keep every lead.